IMPORTANT NOTICE: This is a REFERRAL SERVICE ONLY. We are NOT a law firm and do NOT provide legal services. All legal work is conducted by independent SRA-regulated solicitors.

Over 30 Years Experience

The Association of Contentious Trust and Probate Specialists

0800 29 800 29
Contact

The Financial & Emotional Toll of Unfair Wills: You’re Not Being Greedy, You’re Seeking Fairness

Contact Us

contact

For a free initial conversation call

0800 29 800 29

Feeling guilt contesting a will is a normal emotional response, but seeking fair provision under the Inheritance Act 1975 is your legal right, not greed. Unfair wills emotional impact can be profound, causing financial vulnerability, mental distress, and fractured family relationships. Recognising the emotional toll is crucial, as is understanding your legal standing to challenge a Will for reasonable financial provision, ensuring your true needs and the deceased’s unwritten moral obligations are met.

unfair wills

How it Actually Feels

The loss of a loved one plunges you into a world of profound grief. Amidst this raw sorrow, to discover that their Will has left you unfairly treated, financially vulnerable, or completely disinherited, can feel like a second, brutal blow. It’s an injustice that often ignites powerful emotions: confusion, anger, and a deep sense of betrayal.

Yet, as these feelings churn, another insidious emotion frequently surfaces: guilt. You might hear an internal voice, or even an external one, whispering, “Am I being greedy? Should I just accept it?”

We understand this profound struggle. We know that feeling guilt contesting will is a normal, almost instinctive reaction. Our empathetic approach begins with a simple truth: You are not being greedy; you are seeking fairness. You are seeking to honour the true spirit of your loved one, or to secure the financial stability you genuinely need and deserve. This article aims to validate your feelings, empower you with knowledge, and assure you that pursuing justice is a legitimate and often necessary act of self-preservation.

The Hidden Cost: Beyond the Financial Impact of Unfair Wills

When a Will is unfair, the immediate and obvious consequence is often financial hardship. You might face:

  • Housing Insecurity: Being forced to sell your home, or unable to afford mortgage payments, especially if you lived with the deceased.
  • Lost Livelihood: Inability to maintain your standard of living, fund essential care, or even cover daily expenses.
  • Uncertain Future: Anxiety about retirement, children’s education, or covering unforeseen medical costs without the expected inheritance.

But the toll of an unfair will emotional impact extends far deeper than pounds and pence. It can leave lasting scars that affect every aspect of your well-being.

The Emotional Landscape: Grief, Betrayal, and Invalidation

The grief following a death is complex enough. An unfair Will adds layers of specific, acute emotional distress:

  • Betrayal: You may feel betrayed by the deceased, particularly if you dedicated years to their care, or if promises were made regarding your inheritance. This can profoundly complicate the grieving process.
  • Invalidation: An unfair Will can feel like a public declaration that your relationship with the deceased held little value. This can be deeply invalidating, causing you to question your entire shared history.
  • Anger and Resentment: Towards the deceased, the person who benefited unfairly, or even the legal system itself. This anger can be corrosive if left unaddressed.
  • Anxiety and Stress: The financial uncertainty, combined with the emotional pain, can lead to overwhelming anxiety, affecting sleep, concentration, and overall mental health.
  • Fractured Family Relationships: Will disputes often pit family members against each other, irrevocably damaging bonds and adding further stress to an already traumatic time.

These are not trivial feelings; they are legitimate responses to a profound injustice. They underscore why the decision to contest a Will is rarely, if ever, driven by simple “greed.”

The Guilt Trap: Why We Question Our Right to Fairness

The feeling of guilt contesting will is surprisingly common, yet profoundly misplaced. It stems from several powerful societal and personal pressures:

  • “Don’t Speak Ill of the Dead”: Society often teaches us not to challenge the deceased’s final wishes, even if those wishes are demonstrably unfair or the result of manipulation.
  • Fear of Being Labelled “Greedy”: No one wants to be seen as selfish, especially during a time of mourning. The idea of “fighting over money” can feel undignified.
  • Family Pressure: Other family members, often those who benefit from the unfair Will, may actively shame you, reinforcing the guilt.
  • Emotional Exhaustion: Grief makes you vulnerable. The sheer effort of contemplating a legal challenge can feel overwhelming, making acceptance seem like the easier path, despite the injustice.

It is crucial to recognise that this guilt is a manifestation of your desire for harmony and your reluctance to cause further distress. However, it should not prevent you from seeking justice.

Shifting the Narrative: From Guilt to Legitimate Right

The law, particularly the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, exists precisely because Wills can be unfair, and people can be left in vulnerable positions. This Act allows certain individuals—spouses, partners, children (both minor and adult), and dependents—to claim “reasonable financial provision” from an estate if the Will or intestacy rules failed to provide it.

Your Right to “Reasonable Financial Provision”

The term “reasonable financial provision” is key. It means the court considers:

  • Your Financial Needs: Your current and future expenses, income, and resources.
  • The Size of the Estate: How much wealth is actually available.
  • The Deceased’s Obligations: Any moral or financial obligations the deceased had towards you.
  • Your Relationship with the Deceased: The nature and length of your connection.

Crucially, this is not about taking money from someone else’s share simply because you want more. It is about ensuring you have what you reasonably need to maintain your life, often due to a long-standing dependency or a moral obligation the deceased had towards you.

The legal basis for seeking fair financial provision is deeply rooted in UK law. For further insights into the framework that supports such claims, you can explore the comprehensive information provided by the Citizens Advice Bureau on challenging a Will. This resource can help clarify the various grounds for a challenge.

Empowering Yourself: Taking the First Step

Overcoming unfair wills emotional impact and the guilt contesting will requires courage and accurate information. Your decision to seek advice is not a sign of greed; it is a sign of strength and a commitment to upholding the true intentions and responsibilities of the deceased.

  • Acknowledge Your Feelings: It’s okay to feel angry, hurt, or guilty. These emotions are valid.
  • Focus on Fairness, Not Fault: Frame your concern around what is fair and what reflects the deceased’s true, unpressured wishes, or their moral obligations.
  • Seek Expert Advice: A specialist contentious probate solicitor can provide an objective assessment of your case, helping you understand your legal standing without judgment. They can separate the emotional from the legal.

The law exists to correct injustices, particularly when a Will does not reflect genuine wishes or leaves a dependent in hardship. Your journey to contesting a Will is ultimately a quest for resolution, dignity, and a secure future.

What About Family?

Another fear that we usually see with individuals contesting wills, is their fear of losing or breaking the family. Your feelings are valid, and we understand the family conflict that may arise from challenging a will, but let us tell you that it doesn’t have to be this way.

We combined useful tips and strategic, supportive, and professional steps for you to avoid any family conflicts during this process. Make sure to read our guide: How to Talk to Family About a Will Dispute: Turning Helplessness into Hope, for further information on how to navigate this chapter.

Honouring Their True Legacy

The emotional and financial toll of an unfair Will can be immense. Do not let feelings of guilt prevent you from seeking the justice and security you deserve. Our role is to guide you through this complex legal process with empathy and expert authority, ensuring your voice is heard and your rightful provision is secured.

You’re not being greedy; you’re seeking fairness for yourself and honouring what your loved one would truly have wanted.

If you suspect an unfair Will, contact Contest A Will Today for a confidential, compassionate discussion about your legal options. Let us help you find your path to justice. Get your free, no-obligation case assessment. Call 08002980029 or visit contestawilltoday.com

FAQs

1. Who is legally eligible to make a claim for financial provision under the Inheritance Act 1975?

The Act defines a specific list of people who can claim, extending beyond just immediate family. Eligible categories include the deceased’s spouse or civil partner, a former spouse or civil partner (who has not remarried), a child (of any age), any person treated by the deceased as a child of the family, and, crucially, any person who was financially maintained wholly or partly by the deceased immediately before death. This list ensures that those with a genuine claim to dependency or moral obligation are covered, regardless of the Will’s terms.

2. My relative’s Will includes a “No Contest” clause, threatening to disinherit me if I challenge it. Is this enforceable?

In the UK, clauses designed solely to intimidate beneficiaries into accepting an unfair Will—often called in terrorem or “no contest” clauses—are generally unenforceable in contentious probate law, particularly when the challenge is brought under the Inheritance Act 1975. The law supports the right of dependents to seek reasonable financial provision. A solicitor will assess the clause’s validity, but you should not let fear of such a threat prevent you from seeking expert advice regarding a legitimate claim.

3. Does the duration of my dependency matter if I was financially maintained by the deceased?

Yes, the nature and duration of your dependency are critical factors the court considers when assessing your claim for maintenance under the 1975 Act. The court looks closely at the financial arrangements and the length of time the deceased was providing for you. Demonstrating a long-standing, settled, and significant financial reliance strengthens your case, as it helps prove that the deceased had a continuing moral obligation to provide for your maintenance, which the Will failed to meet.








contact

For a free initial conversation call

0800 29 800 29

Frequently asked questions.

Disputes over wills can arise in several circumstances, including:

  • Testamentary capacity: The person who made the will (known as the testator) must have had the mental capacity to understand what they were doing and the consequences of their actions. This means that they must have been able to understand the nature and extent of their property, the people they were giving their property to, and the people they were excluded from their will.

 

  • Valid execution: The will must have been executed correctly under the law. This means it must be in writing, signed by the testator, and witnessed by two independent witnesses.

 

  • Undue influence: The testator must have made the will freely and without any pressure from others. The will may be invalid if someone was unduly influenced to make a will. Undue influence can occur when someone takes advantage of a testator’s vulnerability, such as if the testator is elderly, ill, or has a mental disability.

 

  • Fraud or forgery: If the will was forged or if someone fraudulently induced the testator to make the will, the will may be invalid.

 

Claims against a will must usually be made within six months of the grant of probate being issued. This is the legal document that gives the executor the authority to administer the estate. If a claim is not made within this time, it may be too late to challenge the will.

As such, executors often wait until this six-month period has expired before distributing the estate. This is to avoid having to distribute the estate and then having to take it back if a successful claim is made against the will.

Here are some examples of how these disputes can arise:

  • A family member may dispute a will if they believe that the testator did not have the mental capacity to make a will. For example, if the testator was suffering from dementia or Alzheimer’s disease at the time the will was made.
  •  

A family member may dispute a will if they believe that it was not executed correctly. For example, if the will is not signed by the testator or if it is not witnessed by two independent witnesses.

 

  • A family member may dispute a will if they believe that they were unduly influenced to make the will. For example, if a caregiver or another family member pressured the testator to make the will in their favour.

 

  • A family member may dispute a will if they believe that it was forged or if someone fraudulently induced the testator to make the will. For example, if someone forged the testator’s signature on the will or if someone lied to the testator about the contents of the will.

If you are thinking about disputing a will, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible. We can assess your case and advise you on your legal options.



Types of Trusts

Many different types of trusts can be set up, depending on your specific needs and goals. Some of the most common types of trusts include:
Bare Trusts: A bare trust is a simple type of trust in which the trustee holds the assets for the benefit of the beneficiary. The beneficiary is entitled to the income and capital of the trust as soon as they are old enough to receive them.

Interest in Possession Trusts: An interest in possession trust is a type of trust in which the beneficiary is entitled to the income from the trust immediately, but not to the capital until a later date. This type of trust is often used for minor beneficiaries or for beneficiaries who are not yet responsible enough to manage their own money.

Discretionary Trusts: A discretionary trust is a type of trust in which the trustee has the discretion to decide how and when to distribute the income and capital of the trust to the beneficiaries. This type of trust is often used for families with multiple beneficiaries or beneficiaries with special needs.

Accumulation Trusts: An accumulation trust is a type of trust in which the income from the trust is accumulated and not distributed to the beneficiaries until a later date. This type of trust is often used to save for a specific purpose, such as a child’s education or a retirement fund.

Mixed Trusts: A mixed trust is a type of trust that combines elements of different types of trusts. For example, a trust may be a discretionary trust for one beneficiary and an interest in possession trust for another beneficiary.

Settlor-Interested Trusts: A settlor-interested trust is a type of trust in which the settlor (the person who creates the trust) retains some interest in the trust assets. For example, the settlor may retain the right to receive income from the trust or to appoint the trustee.

Non-Resident Trusts: A non-resident trust is a type of trust that is created and governed by the laws of a country other than the country where the settlor or beneficiaries reside.
Which type of trust is right for you will depend on your specific needs and goals. It is important to consult with an estate planning attorney to discuss your options and choose the type of trust that is best for you.
Here are some examples of how different types of trusts can be used:
A bare trust can be used to hold assets for a minor child until they reach the age of majority.

An interest in possession trust can be used to provide income to a beneficiary who is not yet responsible enough to manage their own money.

A discretionary trust can be used to manage assets for a family with multiple beneficiaries or for beneficiaries with special needs.

An accumulation trust can be used to save for a specific purpose, such as a child’s education or a retirement fund.

A mixed trust can be used to achieve a variety of different goals, such as providing income to one beneficiary and preserving capital for another beneficiary.

A settlor-interested trust can be used to retain some control over trust assets after the settlor has created the trust.

A non-resident trust can be used to reduce estate taxes or to protect assets from creditors.
It is important to note that this is just a brief overview of the different types of trusts. There are many other types of trusts available, and each type of trust has its own specific features and benefits. For more information please visit www.gov.uk/trusts-taxes/types-of-trust

Inheritance trust disputes can be complex and varied, but some common scenarios include:

  • Disputes over the validity of the trust: This can happen if the settlor (the person who created the trust) does not have the mental capacity to create a trust, or if the trust deed was not executed correctly.

 

  • Disputes over the interpretation of the trust deed: If the trust deed is poorly drafted or unclear, it can lead to disputes between the trustees and beneficiaries about how the trust should be administered.

 

  • Disputes over the appointment or removal of trustees: Trustees have a legal duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. If a trustee is not acting in the best interests of the beneficiaries, the beneficiaries may apply to the court to have the trustee removed.

 

  • Disputes over the investment of trust assets: Trustees have a legal duty to invest trust assets prudently. If a trustee makes investments that are too risky or that lose money, the beneficiaries may sue the trustee for breach of duty.

 

  • Disputes over the distribution of trust assets: Trustees have a legal duty to distribute trust assets to the beneficiaries in accordance with the terms of the trust deed. If a trustee distributes trust assets incorrectly, the beneficiaries may sue the trustee for breach of duty.

 

Here are some specific examples of inheritance trust disputes that have occurred in the UK:

  • In one case, a beneficiary disputed the validity of a trust deed on the grounds that the settlor (the person who created the trust) did not have the mental capacity to create a trust at the time it was set up.

 

  • In another case, a beneficiary sued the trustees for breach of duty after the trustees made a number of risky investments that lost money.



  • In a third case, a beneficiary sued the trustees for breach of duty after the trustees distributed trust assets to the beneficiaries in a way that was not in accordance with the terms of the trust deed.

 

Other possible disputes include:

  • A beneficiary was expecting more than what is set out in the trust document. This may be because the beneficiary had a reasonable belief that they would receive more, or because the trust document is unclear about the beneficiary’s entitlement.

 

  • The individual who set up the trust was provided with negligent or misleading advice. If the settlor was not properly advised about the consequences of setting up a trust, or if they were given incorrect information, they may be able to challenge the trust.

 

  • The trust document is either incomplete or unclear about the wishes of the deceased. If the trust document is incomplete or unclear, it can lead to disputes between the trustees and beneficiaries about how the trust should be administered.

 

  • A trustee acts against the best interests of the beneficiary or doesn’t administer the trust correctly. Trustees have a legal duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. If a trustee breaches their duty, the beneficiaries may sue the trustee.

If you are involved in an inheritance trust dispute, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible. We can assess your case and advise you on your legal options.

Contesting a will is challenging the validity of a will. This can be done on a number of grounds, including.

  • The testator (the person who made the will) did not have the mental capacity to make a will.
  • The will was not executed correctly, i.e., it was not signed by the testator or witnessed by two independent witnesses.
  • The testator was unduly influenced to make the will.
  • The will was forged or fraudulent.

 

Contentious probate is any dispute about the administration of a deceased person’s estate. This can include disputes about

  • The validity of the will.
  • The interpretation of the will.
  • The appointment or removal of executors.
  • The distribution of the estate assets.
  • The management of the estate.
  • In the UK, contentious probate is dealt with by the High Court.

 

The main difference between contesting a will and contentious probate is that contesting a will is specifically challenging the validity of the will, while contentious probate can include a wide range of disputes about the administration of an estate.

Here is an example:

Contesting a will: A beneficiary challenges the validity of a will on the grounds that the testator did not have the mental capacity to make a will.

Contentious probate: A beneficiary disputes the interpretation of a will and argues that they are entitled to a larger share of the estate than they have been given.

It is important to note that the two terms are often used interchangeably. For example, a lawyer might say that they are “dealing with a contentious probate matter” when they are actually challenging the validity of a will.

If you are thinking about contesting a will or pursuing a contentious probate claim, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible. We can assess your case and advise you on your legal options.

The time limit for making a contentious probate claim in the UK is six months from the grant of probate. This is the legal document that gives the executor the authority to administer the estate.

If you do not make your claim within this six-month time limit, you may need to apply to the court for permission to make a late claim. The court will only grant permission if you have a good reason for not making your claim on time.

There are a number of factors that the court will consider when deciding whether to grant permission for a late claim, including:

  • Why did you not make your claim on time?
  • The strength of your case.
  • Whether the other beneficiaries will be prejudiced if your claim is allowed to proceed.
  • If the court grants you permission to make a late claim, you will need to file your claim within 28 days.

 

It is important to note that there are some exceptions to the six-month time limit. For example, if the executor has committed fraud or concealed assets from the beneficiaries, the beneficiaries may be able to make a claim after the six-month time limit has expired.

If you are thinking about making a contentious probate claim, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible. A lawyer can assess your case and advise you on the time limits that apply and whether you have a good case.

Here are some examples of when you might be able to make a late contentious probate claim:

  • You were not aware of the death of the deceased until after the six-month time limit had expired.
  • You were unable to make your claim on time because you were ill or incapacitated.
  • The executor has deliberately concealed information from you about the estate.
  • The executor has committed fraud in the administration of the estate.

 

The 12-year limit for making a contentious probate claim in the UK applies to claims for reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act 1975. This means that if you are making a claim for financial provision from an estate, you must do so within 12 years of the date of the deceased’s death.

The reason for the 12-year limit is to encourage people to make their claims as soon as possible after the deceased’s death. This is because it can become more difficult to investigate and prove a claim after a long period of time has elapsed.

If you are unsure whether you are able to make a late contentious probate claim, you should seek legal advice.

Most disputes in the UK are resolved out of court through mediation and negotiation. This is because it is generally faster, cheaper, and less stressful for all involved.

If you are considering disputing a will, it is important to contact a contentious probate specialist before you involve any other relatives or beneficiaries of the estate. A specialist lawyer can advise you on your legal options and help you to resolve the dispute quickly and efficiently.

Here are some of the benefits of resolving a will dispute out of court:

  • It is faster and cheaper than going to court.
  • It is less stressful for all involved.
  • It allows you to maintain relationships with other family members and beneficiaries.
  • You have more control over the outcome of the dispute.

 

There are a number of steps that you can take to try to resolve a contentious probate dispute without going to court, including

  • Negotiation: You can try to negotiate a settlement with the other parties to the dispute. This may involve making concessions on your part, but it can be a good way to avoid the time and expense of court proceedings.
  • Mediation: Mediation is a process where an independent mediator helps the parties to reach a mutually agreeable settlement. Mediation can be a good way to resolve a dispute without going to court, but it is important to note that it is not binding on the parties.
  • Arbitration: Arbitration is a more formal process than mediation, and it is binding on the parties. However, it can still be a good way to resolve a dispute without going to court.

 

If you are unable to resolve the dispute amicably, you will need to file a claim with the High Court. The court will then hold a hearing to decide the case.

Contact our Team

For a free initial conversation call

0800 29 800 29

email Us

News and Insights